• Design Portfolio
  • See your home in 3D
  • Services
  • Renovate or Relocate
  • Lookbooks
  • Media
  • Resource Articles
  • Contact
Menu

Mark MacInnis Architect

Modern Contemporary Melbourne Architect
  • Design Portfolio
  • See your home in 3D
  • Services
  • Renovate or Relocate
  • Lookbooks
  • Media
  • Resource Articles
  • Contact
×

Blogs

Why did your extension quote come back double?

Dan MacInnis November 16, 2026

In short: when an extension quote comes back far over budget, it is rarely because the builder is greedy. It is usually because the design was drawn before anyone set a number, the drawings left too much open for a builder to price, and the site and the existing house held costs nobody had looked for. All three can be fixed before drawings start.

Key takeaways

•          A quote that blows the budget usually traces back to decisions made before the builder was involved.

•          Allowances in a quote (prime cost items and provisional sums) are estimates, and Consumer Affairs Victoria advises avoiding them where possible.

•          The site and the existing house carry costs that a per square metre rate does not cover.

•          Comparing two quotes only works if they price the same scope.

•          The cheapest point to find the real number is before anything is drawn.

What does it mean when a quote “comes back double”?

It means the design and the budget were never tested against each other until the end. You set a figure in your head, a design was drawn, and the first time anyone priced the whole thing was when a builder quoted it.

By then you have paid for design, sometimes engineering and permits too. That is the situation I hear about most from people who come to me after a first attempt has stalled, and it matches what homeowners write about publicly. In October 2026, 229 public forum posts and reviews by Australian homeowners planning an extension or renovation were read and sorted for this practice. Thirteen of the 139 complaints were from people who had paid for plans they then could not afford to build, and almost a third of all complaints (45) were about cost.

The good news is that the causes are predictable.

Why do extension quotes come in so far over budget?

There are five usual reasons. Most quotes that disappoint have two or three of them at once.

1. The design was drawn before the number was set

If the brief says “a bigger kitchen and a family room” but not “and it must come in at this figure”, the design will grow to fit the wish list. Every decision feels reasonable on its own. Nobody adds them up until the quote arrives.

A budget belongs in the brief, next to the rooms. It should shape the design from the first sketch, not be checked against it at the end.

2. The brief kept growing

A second bathroom while we are at it. Skylights in the hall. Raking ceilings in the living room. Each addition is small, and each one is drawn, so the quote prices all of them. If nobody re-checks the number as the design develops, the brief that gets quoted is not the brief you started with.

3. The drawings left too much open

A builder can only price what is shown. Where the drawings and specification leave a choice open, the quote fills it with an allowance or with a margin for risk.

Victoria’s building contracts recognise two kinds of allowance:

•          Prime cost items are fixtures and fittings that have not been chosen or priced when the contract is signed, such as taps, door handles, tiles and cooktops.

•          Provisional sums are estimates for work the builder cannot price yet, such as excavation where the soil conditions are unknown.

If the real cost comes in higher than the allowance, you pay the difference. That is why the Building and Plumbing Commission says provisional sums should be avoided where possible, and Consumer Affairs Victoria recommends specifying makes, models and prices in the contract so the cost is final. A quote with a long list of allowances can look affordable and still end up well over budget.

4. The site was an unknown

What sits under and around an extension is priced before anything you can see. Much of Melbourne’s south east sits on reactive clay, and the site classification under AS 2870, the Australian Standard for residential slabs and footings, sets the footing design. A slope, narrow side access that limits machinery, or an easement along a boundary all add cost the same quiet way.

None of that is in a per square metre rate. If nobody commissioned a soil report or a land survey before the design, the builder prices the risk instead.

5. The existing house came into the price

Joining new to old means the old part has to keep up. Electrics, plumbing runs and heating often need upgrading, and older houses hold repairs nobody knew about until a wall came off. A rate per square metre covers the new part. It does not cover what the new part reveals about the existing house.

Is a per square metre figure wrong, then?

No, but it is only a starting point. For an architect designed extension in Melbourne, around $5,000 per square metre is a realistic place to start, before kitchens and bathrooms. A quote that looks like “double” is often a whole project price being compared with a build rate that never included wet areas, demolition, service upgrades, design, permits or a contingency.

How much does a house extension cost in Melbourne? sets out what sits inside that rate and what sits outside it.

How do you compare two extension quotes?

Line them up on scope before you look at the totals. For each quote, check:

•          What is included and excluded. Demolition, site works, service upgrades, landscaping and making good to the existing house are common gaps.

•          The list of allowances. Total the prime cost items and provisional sums, and ask how each figure was reached. The law requires your builder to calculate them with reasonable care, and the contract must set them out.

•          What the quote assumes about the site. If one builder has allowed for excavation in rock and another has not, they are not quoting the same job.

The cheapest total is often the one with the most left out.

How do you stop it happening on your project?

Change the order. Find out what your extension will really cost before you pay for drawings.

1.        Set the number first. Decide what you can spend, including a contingency, and put it in the brief.

2.        Test the brief against the number. Some wishes will not fit. It is far cheaper to find that out in a conversation than in a quote.

3.        Investigate the site early. A soil report and survey turn two of the biggest unknowns into known costs.

4.        Specify before you tender. The more selections that are made and written down, the fewer allowances a builder has to guess at.

5.        Re-check the cost as the design develops, not only at the end.

Sometimes the honest answer is that the extension costs more than moving would. Extending vs moving lays out the costs on both sides, and the renovate or relocate calculator gives you a first read in a few minutes.

What if you already have drawings and a quote you cannot afford?

You do not always have to start again. A design can often be reworked to bring the cost down while keeping what matters most to you, by moving fewer walls, keeping the kitchen and bathrooms where the plumbing already is, or building a little less and building it well. What drives the cost of a custom home goes through which decisions move the number most.

Frequently asked questions

Why is my extension quote so much higher than the cost per square metre I saw online? Most per square metre figures cover the build only. A full quote also includes kitchens, bathrooms, demolition, site works and upgrades to the existing house, which can make it look like double.

What are prime cost items and provisional sums? Prime cost items are fixtures and fittings not yet chosen or priced when the contract is signed. Provisional sums are estimates for work the builder cannot price yet, such as excavation. If the real cost is higher than the allowance, you pay the difference.

How do I compare extension quotes from different builders? Compare scope before totals. Check what each quote includes and excludes, add up the allowances, and confirm what each builder has assumed about the site.

How can I find out what my extension will cost before paying for drawings? Start with a feasibility study. It tests your brief against your site, the planning controls and a realistic budget, so the design starts from a number rather than ending at one.

Know the number before you draw

My Feasibility Study is three sessions to work out what your site allows, what you actually need and what it is likely to cost, before you commit to drawings. You can see the services I offer, or book a Feasibility Study and we will start with the number.

In Extensions, Planning and Feasibility Tags extension quote over budget
← Architect, building designer, drafter or builder: who should you call first for an extension?How much does a house extension cost in Melbourne? →

Search Posts

No results found
 

Featured Posts

Complimentary Meeting
Checklist of how to work with Architect
young-millennial-man-working-on-his-macbook-laptop-picjumbo-com.jpg
Resource Articles

Here is a video we created today about our architectural process.

Mark's philosophy on design
Resource Articles RSS

Newsletter Block
This newsletter signup form needs a storage option. Edit the block and enter a storage location via the Storage tab.

Design insights for people planning to build or renovate

Practical ideas on renovations, extensions and creating homes that feel considered—not overdone.

We respect your privacy.

Thank you! We can’t wait to send you our latest newsletter. Why not follow mark on Instagram in the meantime.

Instagram Houzz Articles Lookbooks
© Mark MacInnis Architect · Melbourne